Elena listens in as Clay, Jeremy and Nick discuss the problem with the mutts. Elena surmises that at the rate the mutts have been dumping bodies at Stonehaven that they cannot be far. She adds that Marsten arrived quickly when Nick called. Elena suggests that they search between Stonehaven and Syracuse but Jeremy refuses because the plan is not strategic. Jeremy then says that he is willing to listen to what Santos has to say, though he cannot be trusted. Elena stands and demands to be the bait but Jeremy asserts that they will find the mutts together. Elena walks out in a huff.
We get a flashback to four years ago with Clay, Peter and Nick walking through the hallways of a school. They stop outside of Clay's office and find Elena waiting to see Clay about a job. Peter and Nick excuse themselves and Clay introduces himself and asks Elena to come back tomorrow. Clay watches her walk away and Peter jokes that Elena put a blush on Clay's face. Clay asserts that nothing is going to happen.
In present day, the sheriff's department find Michael Braxton's abandoned truck at the edge of Stonehaven. William's suggest that there is some Manson family level stuff going on but Morgan is not sure.
Clay approaches Elena to tell her that she might be onto something with Marsten but Elena dismisses the suggestion, reminding Clay that they have been given their orders. Clay suggests that they use Nick to cover for them so that they can track down this lead. Elena is shocked that Clay is willing to go against Jeremy. The conversation stops when Clay hears sirens.
Out front, Clay tells Morgan that he hasn't seen Braxton since his dog attempted to attack Elena. William's points out that Braxton's truck was found by the property line and Morgan adds that there was a trail of blood which leads from the truck to the land. Clay points out that if he did anything to Braxton, he wouldn't leave the truck at the edge of the property. Morgan is worried that when words gets out about this that the townspeople are going to start pointing fingers at the Danvers Clan. Clay asserts that he didn't do anything and Jeremy offers the sheriff the right to search his property. The sheriff leaves to round up people for the search.
Jeremy and Clay head inside saying that the wolves will be helping with the search. Elena immediately declares that this is Marsten's doing. Clay says that Braxton's body could be out there and Jeremy adds that if Braxton is here, this is the best chance to mitigate the situation. Jeremy does not want the police to get a search warrant for the house.
The locals arrive and the townspeople are not happy that the Danvers people are going to help with the search. Due to the reaction, Jeremy quickly excuses himself and Clay from the search.
In another flashback, Elena is walking back and forth in front of Clay's office, practicing what she is going to say and Clay overhears each word. Clay opens the door and lets Elena in the office. It seems that in one night, Elena read Clay's book and she tells him that she really wants this job. Clay tells Elena that he is not sure this is going to work out and points out that she might not know a lot about his specialty. Elena asserts that she is self sufficient, so Clay tests her by asking her to spell a word. Elena tells him to stop looking for reasons not to hire her and heads for the door. Clays stops Elena and spells the word for her.
Back at Stonehaven, Nick, Travis and Elena pair up, with Travis making it clear that he is there to keep an eye on Elena in case she decides to tamper with anything she finds.
Victor is meeting with the warden about his pending release from prison. It seems that the warden has reservations about Victor's release and points out that the parole board turned him down three times for good reason. Victor says that he needed to stay in there to keep his nose clean. Victor claims that he found love online with Amber and that he is a clean man. From the conversation, Victor seems to prey on young women.
In the house, Clay is pacing about not being on the search party. Jeremy points out that it would be good for Clay to be there when Daniel arrived. Clay again argues that Daniel cannot be trusted. Jeremy brings up when he first found Clay as a feral little boy and how he waited for Clay to trust him.
Elena is walking through the woods when she gets a call from Diane demanding to know when she is coming home. Elena of course says that it's complicated, so Diane points out that Beckie's other bridesmaid is in a tailspin and they need help with the wedding. It seems that Beckie wants Elena to replace her sick bridesmaid, which means that Elena needs to return ASAP. Philip grabs the phone and apologises for the ambush and Elena tells Philip that she would be honoured to play a role in the wedding. They end the call and Diane asks when Elena is coming back. Philip tells Diane that he doesn't know and that the funeral was two days ago. Diane is suspicious that Elena didn't want Philip at the funeral. Nick and Elena talk about the conversation she had, as it seems he used his wolf hearing to listen in.
In another flashback, Elena is helping Clay pack up his office and Clay keeps giving her an intense look. Elena assures Clay that some university will be lucky to have him and that she will survive. Clay says that he cannot pack because he is not ready to go and has never felt this way before. Elena admits that she feels the same way and takes Clay's hand. The two share a sweet kiss, which quickly gets more passionate. Clay and Elena end up making love on the sofa in his office.