Jacob is playing at the park with Jenny and when she asks if he has any other kids to play with, Jacob admits that he has no friends.
Bellamy, Maggie and Tom have gathered in Rachel's hotel room because no one has seen her since the incident at the church the day before. Maggie reminds Tom that Rachel has family out of town and when that is rejected, she suggests that Rachel could have disappeared like Caleb. Bellamy wonders if Jacob could sense Maggie, since Jacob is the one who helped them track down Caleb.
Fred enters the local bar and meets with Henry for breakfast. Henry brings up stopping by the old factory and wondering if it could be reopened. Fred is quick to deny this as an option because he believes there is no bringing the factory back to life. Henry says that he is feeling optimistic, so Fred questions if Fred really believes the returned boy is Jacob. Henry admits that things have not been easy but when he heard about Caleb disappearing, he was terrified and realized that he could lose Jacob. This is what made Henry realise that Jacob has brought life into his home again.
Lucille is watching Jacob play with Jenny, when she gets a call from Bellamy telling her about Rachel. Lucille agrees to meet Bellamy at the house and calls for Jacob to tell him it's time to leave. Jacob doesn't want to leave, so Lucille has to assert herself several times. Before he leaves, Jacob whispers something to Jenny. When Jacob walks over to Lucille, we see a Black woman walking perpendicular to Jenny. Does this mean that Jenny is another returned child?
Back at the house, Bellamy asks Jacob if he has ever sensed Rachel the way he sensed Caleb. When Jacob says no, Tom tells Jacob that he knew Jenny and that they were in math class together. Jacob again says that he doesn't know and Tom asks him to think a little harder. Jacob starts to wring his hands, as Tom asks him repeatedly to help them. Jacob stands and says that he is scared and doesn't want to but continues to wring his hands.
Rachel is now tied to a chair and she denies knowing Caleb or where he is. Rachel begs for food and water and Gary point out that they have already given her food and water and that she has given them nothing in return. Gary wants to know what Rachel is and where she came from because people don't appear out of nowhere after being dead for 12 years. Gary adds that Jacob could sense Caleb and since Rachel is just like Jacob, she must be able to sense Caleb as well. Gary's co-conspirator's ask for a moment. They ask how much longer they are going to do this because their plan was to only scare Rachel. Gary says that they are not letting Rachel go, so both Paul and Carl declare that they want out. Gary reminds them that they helped kidnapped Rachel and so if they tell anyone, they will be just as culpable as him. When they walk out the door, Rachel begs them to stay and not leave her with Gary.
Eric and Maggie are looking at Jacob's blood and Paul asks to look at Caleb's blood to see if it looks like Jacob's. When Maggie heads over to the fridge, she finds the vials which contained Caleb's blood to be empty.
Tom and Bellamy pull up to the church to see if Rachel is hiding there. In the lot, they see Gary's truck and so ask Bob the gardener if he has seen Gary today. Bob replies that he hasn't seen Gary since yesterday and that Gary's truck has been there all night.
Henry and Lucille put together a puzzle, as a clearly bored Jacob watches. Jacob wants to go back to the park and play with Jenny because he promised her that he would return. Henry tries to encourage Jacob but Jacob is insistent that he wants to return to the park. Lucille tells Jacob that he heard what Bellamy said and that it is best for him to stay home today. Jacob storms up the stairs saying that he is being punished and that he didn't do anything. Lucille moves to follow but Henry stops her saying that an occasional temper tantrum is the right of every eight year old boy. Lucille however points out that Jacob isn't like other eight year old boys. Henry assures Lucille that Jacob will come around.
Bellamy and Tom head to see Fred about Gary but Fred says that he doesn't understand why Gary would do something to Rachel. Tom points out that Gary's truck is still at the church and Belllamy adds that Gary was talking about the Returned like they aren't human. Fred points out that Gary has every right to be angry because of what Caleb did and suggests that Rachel might be embarrassed because of her pregnancy and left town. Out of the corner of his eye, Fred sees Carl making his way into the station. Fred tells Bellamy and Tom that he isn't going to investigate until he has proof that something is wrong. Tom gets angry and says that he is done wasting his time arguing with someone who is ignorant. Fred argues back that he is caught in the middle, so Bellamy promises to let Fred know if something comes up.
Carl is getting dressed in the locker room when Fred walks in to question him as to why he is late. Carl lies and claims that his battery died. Fred slams Carl against the lockers and asks him what he did.
Tom and Bellamy make their way to see Polly Humphrey and ask if Gary is at home. Polly admits that Gary is not at home and wonders if Gary will ever be back. It turns out that Gary started drinking again and that when Gale got killed, it put Gary over the edge. Bellamy assure Polly that he doesn't want Gary to hurt himself or anyone else and asks if Polly has any idea where Gary might be. Polly again says that she doesn't know, so Bellamy asks if there is a place Gary goes when he wants to be alone. Polly tells them about the cabin and Tom stands, promising to tell Polly if they find Gary.
Eric calls Maggie back into the lab to look at a sample of leukemia. Maggie wonders how Eric got a sample of leukemia but instead of answering her, Eric shows Maggie another slide. The second slide actually shows that the cancer has been cured after being introduced to Jacob's white blood cells. Eric is excited and says that he needs to do more tests. Maggie again asks where Eric got the leukemia sample and Eric admits that he was diagnosed last year. Eric says that he is booking a flight for Maryland tonight and tells Maggie that she should go with him.
At the Langstons, Lucille knocks on Jacob's door but doesn't get an answer. Lucille says that she knows it is hard to understand why things are the way they are. When Lucille doesn't get an answer again, she opens the door and finds the room empty.
Gary is drinking and Rachel promises not to say anything if he lets her go home. Gary questions if Rachel has a home and Rachel points out that Arcadia is her home, just like Gary. Unfortunately for Rachel, Gary is quick to tell her that she is nothing like him. Gary says it's time to find out what Rachel is and pulls out a long knife and adds, it's time to find out if Rachel bleeds. Rachel asks Gary if he is sure he wants to do that because she might be the devil and questions if knives can hurt her. Rachel points out that she is already dead, so Gary grabs her and demands to know what she is. Rachel promises to hunt Gary down and show up in his nightmares. The two are interrupted by a loud knock at the door.